What’s the difference between being a Contractor or Employee?

Get the Facts.

Understanding the differences between being an employee and an independent contractor can be challenging. While higher pay rates offered for 1099 contractor positions may seem appealing, it’s crucial for businesses and workers to comply with IRS rules regarding worker classification. Misclassifying an employee as an independent contractor can result in serious legal and financial consequences for businesses.

At Specialized Assessment & Consulting, we are a W-2 agency. Our employees enjoy and thrive in this structure. Our clients also can rest assured that our company follows all IRS rules and legal requirements.

Let’s explore the differences between being an employee and an independent contractor at a contract company like Specialized, along with the unique benefits our employees enjoy.

The Benefits of Being an Employee at Specialized

Employees at Specialized enjoy a wide range of benefits and support that contribute to their professional and personal success:

  1. Support and Training: We provide robust onboarding, ongoing support, and training opportunities tailored to our employees’ needs. Employees also benefit from reimbursement for continuing education units (CEUs).
  2. Health Insurance: Comprehensive health insurance plans are available to employees, ensuring access to quality healthcare.
  3. Professional Liability Insurance: Employees are fully covered under the company’s professional liability insurance, giving them peace of mind while performing their roles.
  4. Referral Bonuses: Employees can earn bonuses by referring qualified professionals to our team.
  5. Company-Sponsored Social Events: From team-building activities to celebrations, our employees enjoy a sense of community and camaraderie.
  6. Company-Provided Supplies: Employees have access to the necessary equipment and technology to perform their roles effectively, including a company email account.

By joining Specialized as an employee, you gain the stability, support, and resources needed to focus on your work and grow your career.

Independent Contractors at Specialized

Independent contractors operate with greater autonomy and are responsible for managing their own businesses. Many professionals, such as speech therapists and special education specialists, find the flexibility of independent contracting appealing. However, contractors must ensure they comply with IRS regulations and establish themselves as legitimate business entities.  As an independent contractor, you are also responsible for your own business marketing, accounting, training and equipment and you are offering your services to the general public and looking for clients.

Key Considerations for Worker Classification

The IRS uses a 20-point checklist to determine whether a worker is classified correctly. Below are just six of the critical factors to consider:

  1. Behavioral Control:
    • Does the company control or have the right to control what the worker does and how they perform their job? Employees are often subject to company policies, training, and oversight.
  2. Financial Control:
    • Who has control over the financial aspects of the worker’s job? Independent contractors typically manage their own expenses and may have opportunities to make a profit or incur a loss.
  3. Type of Relationship:
    • Does the worker receive benefits such as insurance, vacation pay, or retirement plans? These benefits often signify an employer-employee relationship.
  4. Investment in Equipment:
    • Independent contractors generally provide their own tools, equipment, and resources, while employees use company-provided supplies and resources.
  5. Opportunity for Profit or Loss:
    • Contractors bear the risk of making a profit or experiencing a loss based on their efficiency and business management. Employees, on the other hand, receive a fixed wage or salary regardless of company performance.
  6. Permanency of Relationship:
    • Is the relationship ongoing or project-based? Employees often have an indefinite relationship with their employer, whereas contractors are usually engaged for specific projects or timeframes.

Why Worker Classification Matters

Understanding and adhering to the legal distinctions between employees and independent contractors is essential. Misclassification can lead to significant penalties for businesses and impact workers’ financial and legal standing. By maintaining compliance, Specialized ensures fair treatment for all team members while fostering a productive work environment.

Employee vs. Contractor: Tax Impact Example

Let’s compare the tax implications for an employee and an independent contractor earning $10,000:

Employee:

  • Gross Earnings: $10,000
  • Taxes Withheld:
    • Federal Income Tax: Approx. $1,000 (depends on tax bracket and withholding allowances)
    • Social Security (6.2%): $620
    • Medicare (1.45%): $145
  • Net Pay: Around $8,235 after taxes (subject to variations based on filing status and deductions).
  • Employer Contributions:
    • Social Security and Medicare: The employer matches 7.65% of the employee’s salary for these taxes.

Independent Contractor:

  • Gross Earnings: $10,000
  • Self-Employment Taxes(15.3% for Social Security and Medicare): $1,530
    • Contractors pay both the employee and employer portions of Social Security and Medicare taxes.
  • Federal Income Tax: Approx. $1,000 (varies based on deductions and taxable income).
  • Net Earnings: Around $7,470 after taxes (before accounting for any business expenses).

Independent contractors can deduct business expenses (e.g., equipment, home office costs, and mileage), which may reduce taxable income. However, they are responsible for managing and paying quarterly estimated taxes.

Resources:

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee

For additional guidance, consult the IRS website and speak with your financial or legal advisors. The above information is not meant to substitute for professional advice.

Interested in Learning More?

Contact us to discuss opportunities with our recruiting team at Specialized.

Book a call here! https://calendly.com/specialized_recruit

Follow Us

At Specialized, our mission is to partner with schools and providers to help every child reach their full potential.

Contact Us

10242 Greenhouse Rd #1701, Cypress, TX 77433

© 2025 Specialized Assessment & Consulting | View our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use | Accessibility Statement
Website by iTech Maker